The Hamptons are synonymous with luxury, relaxation, and breathtaking coastal beauty, but the region is also home to some of the finest dining experiences in New York. Whether you’re enjoying a weekend escape or living in one of its picturesque communities, the restaurants in Hampton offer something for every palate, from classic Italian fare to fresh seafood by the water. In this guide, we explore five of the best restaurants in The Hamptons, each bringing a unique blend of flavors and ambiance to the table.
1. Sant Ambroeus Southampton: Classic Italian Elegance
Located in the heart of Southampton, Sant Ambroeus is the epitome of refined Italian dining. Known for its sophisticated ambiance and timeless menu, this restaurant has long been a favorite among both locals and weekend visitors. With its roots tracing back to Milan, Sant Ambroeus brings authentic Italian cuisine to the East End, focusing on fresh, seasonal ingredients that create rich, flavorful dishes.
Start your meal with their signature Caprese, paired with Kumato tomatoes, before moving on to their perfectly cooked pasta dishes like the fettuccine alla bolognese with veal ragu or the fusilli strofinati. The seafood options also stand out, with dishes like branzino providing a light yet satisfying option for summer dining.
With a mix of indoor and outdoor seating, Sant Ambroeus offers a relaxed but elegant dining experience, making it the perfect spot for both casual lunches and special occasion dinners. This is one of the top restaurants in the Hamptons, where you can indulge in classic Italian flavors with a touch of luxury.
2. Stone Creek Inn: A French-Mediterranean Gem in East Quogue
Nestled in the charming village of East Quogue, Stone Creek Inn has been delivering exceptional French-Mediterranean cuisine to The Hamptons for over two decades. Helmed by Chef Christian Mir, this upscale restaurant offers a menu that balances French culinary techniques with Mediterranean influences, creating an unforgettable dining experience.
Stone Creek Inn’s menu reflects a deep appreciation for local ingredients, with dishes like Scottish salmon and roasted duck breast showcasing the region's finest produce. Foie gras is another must-try; it is rich and expertly prepared, making it a popular choice for those looking to indulge. Complement your meal with one of their carefully curated wines, many of which are sourced from boutique vineyards across France and the Mediterranean.
The elegant yet welcoming atmosphere of Stone Creek Inn, coupled with its exceptional service, ensures that every visit feels like a special occasion. For those seeking fine dining with a Mediterranean twist, this restaurant is a standout in the East Quogue dining scene.
3. Cowfish: Waterfront Dining in Hampton Bays
For a more laid-back, coastal vibe, Cowfish in Hampton Bays is the perfect destination. Perched right on the water, Cowfish combines fresh seafood with Southern-inspired flavors to create a relaxed yet vibrant dining experience. Whether you’re arriving by boat or by car, this casual eatery delivers stunning waterfront views and an equally impressive menu.
Start your meal with a plate of jumbo buffalo shrimp or the ever-popular clam chowder. For mains, the seafood shines—opt for the seared diver scallops or the lobster roll, which is always a crowd favorite. If you're in the mood for something heartier, the BBQ ribs or the house burger will not disappoint.
One of Cowfish's unique aspects is its family-centric atmosphere, making it a great spot for lunch or dinner with children in tow. The open-air dining deck allows you to take in the fresh bay breeze as you enjoy your meal, making this one of the best restaurants in Hampton for relaxed waterfront dining.
4. Nick & Toni’s: A Hamptons Staple in East Hampton
No list of top Hamptons restaurants would be complete without Nick & Toni’s. This East Hampton institution has long been a favorite among celebrities, locals, and weekenders alike. Known for its wood-fired Mediterranean cuisine, Nick & Toni’s creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere while delivering exceptional dishes made with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
The menu changes frequently to reflect what’s in season, but standout dishes include the signature roast chicken with potatoes and rosemary, the Long Island duck breast, and the house-made mushroom risotto. Vegetarians will also appreciate the restaurant's creative, vegetable-forward dishes, while the extensive wine list ensures the perfect pairing for every meal.
With its rustic charm and cozy interior, Nick & Toni’s is a must-visit for anyone visiting East Hampton. The combination of its top-tier food and inviting ambiance has solidified its reputation as one of the most beloved restaurants in Hampton.
5. Cittanuova: Italian Modernity Meets Casual Comfort
For those craving Italian food in a more casual setting, Cittanuova in East Hampton offers a contemporary take on traditional Italian dining. This sleek, modern restaurant serves up everything from wood-fired pizzas to classic pasta dishes, making it a popular spot for both lunch and dinner.
Cittanuova’s menu emphasizes simplicity and quality, with standout items including the Margherita pizza, tagliatelle bolognese, and roasted beet salad. For those looking for something heartier, the grilled meats and seafood are sure to satisfy. The restaurant’s outdoor seating area is perfect for summer days, offering a prime spot for people-watching along the bustling streets of East Hampton.
The combination of modern design, relaxed atmosphere, and approachable menu makes Cittanuova a go-to spot for anyone looking to enjoy a casual yet refined meal in The Hamptons.
Work with The Mackay Dixon Team
If you’ve fallen in love with the dining scene in The Hamptons, why not make this iconic destination your home? If you’re looking to purchase real estate here, The Mackay Dixon Team can provide expert guidance throughout your journey. With extensive experience in The Hamptons market, they offer personalized service and unparalleled knowledge to help you navigate the intricacies of luxury real estate.
The Mackay Dixon Team understands the unique appeal of The Hamptons, from its world-class restaurants to its stunning coastal properties, and they’re here to help you find the perfect home. Let them assist you in making the dream of living in The Hamptons a reality.
*Header image courtesy of Pexels